You might be able to. I know that’s not the satisfying answer, but it’s the honest one, and the good news is that it can be turned into a real yes or no pretty quickly.
Keeping the house comes down to two separate questions: whether you can get the loan into your name alone (and pay it), and whether you actually want this house as a one-income household. People usually spend all their energy on the second one and assume the first one will sort itself out. In my experience, nothing with divorce ever “sorts itself out,” unfortunately.
Wanting it and affording it are two different questions
Wanting to keep the house makes complete sense. It’s where the kids sleep. It’s the school district, the neighbors, the routine, the one thing that doesn’t have to change right now.
None of that is a mortgage question, and I strongly support taking the time and intention needed to discern your personal answer. But the mortgage question is the one that decides whether the plan works, so unpacking that is imperative before anything gets signed.
Can you qualify on your own?
Right now, there’s a chance both of your names are on the loan and both incomes made the numbers work. Keeping the house almost always means a lender looking at your income, debts, and credit—on their own.
That review looks at:
Your income. Pay from work, plus any alimony or child support you’ll receive, if it’s spelled out in your agreement, will continue for at least three years from when you apply, and you can show it’s actually been coming in. (Support income has its own rules and timing traps, and they deserve a post of their own.)
Your monthly debts. Car payments, student loans, credit cards, and any support you’ll be paying all count against what you qualify for.
Your credit. If you’re buying out your ex or taking over the loan, the lender uses your scores and history, not the household’s.
If you’re the one moving out, the same review applies to whatever you buy next, which is another reason to run both sides of these numbers and scenarios sooner than later.
How do you get your ex off the loan?
This is the part that surprises people. The house can be awarded to you in the divorce, and your ex can sign a quitclaim deed, and yet your ex will remain on the mortgage. I walked through why in If My Ex Signs a Quitclaim Deed, Are They Off the Mortgage?, but here’s the tl;dr version: title is legal ownership of the asset, the loan is the debt, and the creditor only cares about the debt.
There are three real ways the person moving out actually gets off the loan:
Refinance into your name alone. A new loan, in your name, pays off the old joint one. You qualify on your own, at today’s rates.
Assume the existing loan. Some loans, including many FHA and VA loans, can be assumed with the lender’s approval. If it works, you keep the existing rate and the other borrower gets released. Get that release of liability in writing.
Sell. The house sells, the loan gets paid off, and you each walk away with your share of any proceeds from the sale.
There’s a fourth thing people try: leaving both names on the loan and agreeing that one of you will pay it. That’s not a way off the loan. Every late payment still lands on both credit reports, and the person who moved out is still carrying that debt when they try to buy their own place (though that payment can possibly be excluded for them, depending on your documentation and the loan program).
Buying out your ex’s equity
If there’s equity in the house, keeping it usually means paying your ex for their share. Often, that money comes from a refinance.
Say, hypothetically, the house is worth $450,000 and you owe $250,000 on it. That’s potentially $200,000 in total equity. If your agreement splits it evenly,* your ex’s share is $100,000. To pay that out of the house, you’d need a new loan of about $350,000 (plus closing costs) in your name alone, on one income.
Two things worth knowing about how that refinance works:
It can be priced better than a regular cash-out refinance. For Fannie Mae conventional loans, you can refinance into your own name regardless of the current title, but buying out your ex’s equity as a limited cash-out refinance requires that the two of you have jointly owned the house (on title) for at least 12 months. Limited cash-out typically reflects better rates & pricing than cash-out refinances.
The money is for your ex, not for you. In that setup, the person keeping the house can’t take any of the proceeds for themselves and escrow will pay out your ex directly.
And here’s the piece that can sting: if your current rate is low, refinancing means trading it for whatever rates are when you refinance. That can potentially change the payment by quite a bit. It’s also exactly why assumption deserves a look before anyone defaults to a refinance as the only option.
The payment is only part of the cost
Even if you qualify, qualifying isn’t the same as comfortable. The lender is checking whether the numbers fit their guidelines, but the only one who can determine how realistic that monthly payment is, is you.
Run the full monthly cost, not just principal and interest: property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance (if your loan has it), and HOA dues if you have them. My mortgage payment calculator breaks those pieces out so you can estimate the real numbers.
Then add the things lenders aren’t accounting for. The water heater is now your water heater. The roof, the lawn, the property tax bill that went up again. In the chaos of it all, looking toward a solo financial future after sharing one for a long time can often be a missed step.
When keeping it makes sense, and when it might not
There’s no universally right answer here, and I’d be super suspicious of anyone who says there is.
Keeping the house tends to pencil out when:
you can qualify on your own with room to breathe, not just squeak by
the payment still works if your income or support is variable
the stability is worth more to you than the equity you’d free up by selling
Letting it go deserves a serious look when:
keeping it means a buyout that stretches you too thin for comfort
the payment on a solo income doesn’t work for your real life
the house would take most of your savings and leave you strapped
Selling isn’t failing. Sometimes it’s the decision that gives you the most room in the next chapter. Sometimes keeping the house is. You’re the only one who gets to weigh that, and hiring the right experts to help you strategize is paramount.
Get the answers before you sign
The best time to figure all this out is before the agreement is final. Once the terms are set...them’s the terms, for better or worse.
A few things worth settling in writing with your ex, your attorney, or the mediator:
Who is keeping the house, and by what date the loan has to be refinanced or assumed
What happens if the person keeping it can’t qualify by that date
How the equity is being split, and whether it’s coming from a refinance, other agreement, or a sale
What support is being paid, how much, and for how long
I don’t replace your attorney, mediator, or CPA. I just make sure the mortgage part of the plan actually works before it’s locked in. I’ve completed extensive specialized training in Divorce Mortgage Planning for this exact reason, and am qualified to testify in divorce trials accordingly. My Divorce + Mortgage Planning page walks through more of the questions that come up, and the Divorce & the House section of my FAQ has quick answers to the rest.
*When splitting equity, important consideration needs to be given for property taxes in arrears, costs/fees of refinancing, and potential realtor commissions and closing costs in a sale. “Splitting evenly” isn’t necessarily the actual equitable division.
General information, not legal or tax advice. Loan program rules vary, and every situation is different.
Source: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.4-02, Alimony, Child Support, Equalization Payments, or Separate Maintenance; HUD Handbook 4000.1

